Game Day Eats: Pimento Cheeseburger Recipe

by | Feb 9, 2024

We’re gearing up for the Big Game this weekend by adding our favorite Northwest beers to the line-up. And what better accompaniment to a brew than a delicious Pimento Cheeseburger?”

We pulled this cult classic from our vault to share a unique, wildly delicious burger recipe from the beloved shuttered Trifecta restaurant in PDX. Add it to your menu and raise a glass, no matter which team you’re rooting for. 

The Juicy Details: Portland’s Trifecta Tavern, once led by the renowned executive chef Rich Meyer alongside the expertise of Ken Forkish, had established itself as a burger authority. Their signature creation featured a blend of ground brisket and chuck, hand-pressed into a loose patty, then grilled over a wood fire and nestled between their house-made brioche bun, generously spread with pimento and special sauce. 

The Burger: Pimento Double Cheeseburger  

Recipe from Executive Chef Rich Meyer, formerly of Trifecta Tavern, Portland 

Makes 1 8-ounce burger (2 4-ounce patties) 

Ingredients

8 ounces brisket and chuck, or chuck only, divided into two 
1 ½ cups white cheddar, grated 
1 cup mayonnaise 
1 Calabrian chili 
½ cup Mama Lil’s pickled peppers 
1 teaspoon garlic, chopped 
Trifecta’s Special Sauce (recipe follows) 
1 brioche bun, sliced 

With your hands, gently work the meat to form two patties. Set aside.  

For the pimento cheese, purée the cheddar, mayonnaise, chili and pickled peppers in food processor until combined. Add salt and pepper to taste and chopped garlic, purée for 10 seconds more. Makes about 1 pint.  

Bring the grill to high. Season the patties as they hit the grilling surface with salt and freshly ground pepper. Cook the meat patties to desired doneness. Flip the patty, add 1 ounce of pimento cheese and remove from heat. Place sliced brioche bun on the grill, slice side down, until golden brown. Smear bottom bun with Special Sauce as well as the top bun. Stack the patties between the brioche halves and serve immediately.  

Trifecta’s Special Sauce 

Makes about 1 ½ cups  

Ingredients: 

1 cup mayonnaise 
1 Calabrian chili, puréed 
1 tablespoon ketchup 
2 tablespoons dill pickle, minced 
Salt and black pepper to taste 
Sherry vinegar to taste (1 to 2 teaspoons) 

In a bowl, mix all ingredients. Set aside. 

Photo by Blue Rose Photography 

Sip Magazine

what’s new

All Day
Featured

Winter Beer Fest 2024

Victory Hall at the Boxyard 1201 1st Ave S, Seattle
$60 – $65
Ongoing

Week of Events

WALLA WALLA WINE ON TOUR | BOISE

WALLA WALLA WINE ON TOUR | BOISE

Amaterra’s Holiday Tea

Amaterra’s Holiday Tea

Featured

Winter Beer Fest 2024

Featured

Winter Beer Fest 2024

Print Issue

get the latest

SIGN UP FOR THE SIP MAGAZINE NEWSLETTER.

By subscribing online, you are opting in to receive our Sip Magazine Insider e-newsletter— with the latest coverage in Pacific Northwest beverage scene, product reviews, libation destinations, events + more.